Best Value: Old Forester 100 Proof
Courtesy of Wine.com
Region: Kentucky | ABV: 50% | Tasting Notes: Apple, Spice, Oak
Old Forester must be the best bang for your buck, so if it turns out bourbon is not your thing its no big deal, says Chris Keller, bartender at Osaka Ramen in Denver. Its an authentic bourbon with excellent flavor. Take a sip, then add an ice cube to feel the flavor develop. There are a variety of expressions with different ABVs, but the 100 proof version is one of the best.
Is Rye Whiskey Bourbon Rye Whiskey Vs Bourbon
Given bourbons modern-day prevalence and ryes virtual disappearance after Prohibition, its often asked whether theyre not actually one and the same. Indeed, the overall manufacturing process is similar but the ingredients are somewhat different.
Indeed, it is subject to the same regulations as all American whiskey in that it is distilled up to 80% ABV, aged in charred new oak barrels, and bottled at a minimum of 40% ABV.
However, where rye whiskey must contain a 51% minimum of rye in its mash, bourbon uses the same minimum quantity of corn instead. Since regulations require just over half of either one, it isnt possible to produce a whiskey that can be recognised as both rye and bourbon.
To make matters more confusing, high-rye is also a type of bourbon, which is not officially recognised but a category growing in popularity. This bourbon, however, still requires a minimum of 51% of corn in the mash but it will also contain over 25% rye, too.
Where bourbon was a frontier whiskey, rye was historically produced in the northeastern states. Bourbon eventually adopted its Francophonic name in order to distinguish itself. Rye whiskey never developed its own name since it was so prevalent at the time and this didnt particularly feel necessary.
Most people who develop an interest in rye whiskey are usually keen bourbon enthusiasts first. Indeed, bourbon can be considered the gateway drug to exploring other varieties of American whiskey and rye is the next logical step!
Best Way To Taste Rye Whiskey Flavors
There are two ways to do this. The first is to pour you a shot of Rye whiskey over ice. Although our elderly generation will frown on you for doing this, possibly more than just frowning, its a good way to bring out some of the deeper tones in the whiskey.
Not only that, rye whiskey over ice changes the flavor subtly, so you get to know your Rye whiskey taste in two different ways.
The second way is to sprinkle a few drops of water in it. Science has shown that those few drops of water make your whiskey spring to life in terms of flavor. If you want to find the Rye Whiskey thats right for you, there is no better method than a straight pour, with a light sprinkle of water.
Get to know what Scientific Studies say about Whisky on the Rocks!
Don’t Miss: What Mixers Go With Whiskey
How Do Bourbon And Rye Differ
Bourbon can only be made in the United States, whereas rye whiskey can, and does, come from all over: Canada, the Netherlands, Germany, the U.K., and even Australia.
Nothing, other than water, can be added to bourbon, whether or not it is labeled straight. For rye whiskey, the rules are a little different. Straight rye cannot have any additives, but if the rye isnt labeled as straight, or if its a blend of straight ryes, up to 2.5% of the volume can be harmless coloring/flavoring/blending materials. Since these additives do not have to be disclosed, its impossible to tell which ryes might include them, although Templeton Rye is a well-known example.
Flavor-wise, bourbon tends to be sweeter and has a more oily mouthfeel than rye due to its high corn content. Common flavor notes in bourbon include vanilla, caramel, nuts, oak, dark fruit, chocolate, and mild spice.
Rye whiskeys flavor profile can vary considerably depending on its overall rye content. A minimum-51% rye, like those traditionally made by the big Kentucky distilleries, will taste quite similar to bourbon. But 100% ryea style that often comes from Canadatypically has rich spice and herbal notes, enhanced by flavors derived from barrel aging such as vanilla and oak.
Similar Drinks & Rye Whiskey Substitutes
Unsurprisingly, rye whiskeys next of kin is bourbon. Although we said earlier that comparisons between the two were often unfair, they are also inevitable since theyre so closely related.
For this reason, its not uncommon for rye whiskey cocktail recipes like the Manhattan or the Sazerac to use bourbon instead of the original ingredient. Indeed, bourbons popularity made it a frequent substition.
Nevertheless, these are still best served with rye given that they were intended to benefit from the whiskeys natural spiciness. Since bourbon is comparatively sweet, it tends to soften the flavour and lose out on complexity.
Since whiskey is a diverse family of spirits, there are plenty of other substitutions, though. Canadian whisky, if properly made with the main ingredient, will offer a very similar experience to American rye whiskey.
Otherwise, you may consider Scotch whiskey. Yet, Scotch is produced from malted barley and is aged in used bourbon barrels. Consequently, it will have a buttery and savoury flavour, but those from certain regions like Speyside can deliver some spiciness.
Meanwhile, Irish whiskey may be considered too light and floral to be considered as an appropriate substitute for ryes bold and peppery profile.
Also Check: Where To Buy Bellion Vodka
With Unique Flavors Basil Hayden’s Dark Rye Whiskey Is Our Winner
We independently research, test, review, and recommend the bestproductslearn more about our process. If you buy something through our links, we may earn a commission.
Liquor / Chloe Jeong
Spicy, bold, and part of Americas spirit history, rye whiskey is becoming an increasingly popular option for both cocktailians and those who prefer their whiskey straight.
Historically, we were a very rye-focused culture before we discovered it was easier in most of the U.S. to distill with corn and barley malt, says Jena Ellenwood, bartender at Dear Irving and Sparrow Tavern in New York City. Rye was harder to grow in the soil, and it tended to have more spice than the sweet corn.
Popular in the 1940s and 50s, rye went through a bit of a slump until the early 2010s when demand grew again. Now, there are plenty of quality rye whiskeys available on the market, some crafted for sipping straight, while others punch through in cocktails. With rye whiskey, the question becomes not just one of aroma and flavor, but of body and heat, as well, says Alicia Yamachika, lead bartender at Nobu Honolulu.
After consulting industry experts, Basil Hayden’s Dark Rye Whiskey tops our list of rye whiskeys thanks to its unique flavor profile.
Read on to find out the best bottles of rye to drink and mix with.
Region: Kentucky, Canada, California | ABV: 40% | Tasting Notes: Spice, Dried fruit, Molasses
What Does Irish Whiskey Taste Like
Irish whiskey is a distilled beverage with an alcohol content typically ranging from 40% to 95%.
The standard service in Ireland is a single measure.
Irish whiskey has an earthy, peaty, and smoky taste with hints of sweetness on the finish.
The malt gives it that sweet, caramel flavor, and the grain gives it that smooth finish.
Alcohol, malt, vanilla cream, orchard fruit, and marmalade are the main flavors in Irish whiskey.
You May Like: What Mixes Good With Peanut Butter Whiskey
What Is Rye Malt Whiskey
Rye malt or malted rye whiskey is almost identical to regular rye whiskey except for one extra albeit vital step. On this occasion, the rye is malted beforehand, which involves soaking the grain in water so it cracks open and begins to germinate before halting the process by drying it.
In order to bear the rye malt name, the mash bill must feature 51% malted rye. However, regular rye can still be used in the remaining 49%, too. Rye is arguably spicier when malted and will add an even more distinctive peppery kick to the overall flavour.
Have You Tried Tennessee Whiskey
Tennessee whiskey is a type of bourbon. It adheres to all the requirements of bourbon, but with an additional step. Tennessee bourbon has to be filtered through sugar-maple charcoal prior to barreling. It also, of course, must be made and aged in Tennesee. A modern example of great Tennessee whiskey is Bob Dylans Heavens Door.
Heavens Door Whiskey
You buy Heavens Door at South Lyndale Liquors
Recommended Reading: How To Make Vodka Shots
What Is Bourbon Made From
Bourbon whiskey is made from a mash of at least 51% corn, with the remainder being a combination of other grains. The grain mix, or mashbill, can vary depending on the distiller, but often includes rye and barley. Straight rye whiskey must be made from at least 51% rye grain.
he grain mixture is combined with water and yeast, and fermented to create a beer-like wash. This wash is then distilled to produce whiskey. The whiskey is then aged in oak barrels, which give bourbon its characteristic flavor profile. Finally, the whiskey is bottled and sold.
The Flavor: What Does Rye Taste Like Vs Bourbon
But the more important question is: what are the flavor differences between rye whiskey vs bourbon? In general, rye is known for its spicy finish and bourbon is a little sweeter and rounder. Of course, this does vary based on brand! Weve tasted a bourbon was grassy and grain-forward, followed by a rye that was bright with a sweeter body.
- Rye whiskey tastes grassy and peppery, with a signature spicy finish. Depending on the brand, there may may be notes of oak, smoke or fruit. Rye is generally spicier with a more aggressive flavor than bourbon.
- Bourbon whiskey typically has a sweeter, more mellow flavor than rye, with notes of vanilla, oak and caramel. But theres a wide variety of different flavors between bourbon brands: one expert breaks bourbons into 4 major categories: grain forward, nutmeg forward, caramel forward, and cinnamon forward.
Whats the difference vs Scotch? Read more at Bourbon vs Scotch.
Read Also: What To Do With Spiced Rum
Other Fun Whisky Facts:
- What is malted barley?
- Raw barley that has been soaked, germinated, and then dried to halt the germination process. In Scotch, the drying process often happens using burning peat, imparting in varying degrees Scotchs classic smoky, peaty flavor.
We hope this helps unlock a few of the mysteries between the different types of whiskeys. Of course the only thing to really do that is to go out there and taste them. Find what you like and enjoy it!
Favorite Barware
Wheat: Wheated Bourbons & Wheat Whiskeys
Why do people go crazy-go-nuts over Pappy Van Winkle? One of the things that distinguishes it from other bourbon is the wheat in the mash, which really does taste a bit like whole wheat bread with honey However, you dont need to drop mad cash on Pappy in order to taste a wheated bourbon whiskey. Try any of the range of solid W.L. Weller bourbons, , and if you cant find that, good ol Makers Mark or Rebel Reserve, will fit the wheated bourbon bill.
Pappy Van Winkles Family Reserve 20 Year / Photo Credit: Old Rip Van Winkle Distillery
For the full wheat experience opt for wheat whiskey with very high percentages of wheat in the mash bill: Bernheim Original Wheat, 1792 Sweet Wheat, or Mastersons Straight Wheat Whiskey. You could also take a trip across the pond and seek out Haig Club Single Grain which is made from 90% wheat.
Recommended Reading: How To Sell Whiskey On The Secondary Market
What Does Whiskey Taste Like Compared To Beer
Whiskey and beer have more in common than most other beverageswhich makes sense, considering that whiskey can be made by distilling beer. They both owe their main flavors to grains, but thats about where the similarities of taste end.
Beer has a far lower ABV and, therefore, is not as strong on the palate. Beer is typically 5%, whereas whiskeys ABV typically ranges between 40% and 50%.
While beer predominately tastes bitter and hoppy, whiskey frequently tastes very sweet. Bitter whiskey is often stored and aged in casks that are charred white oak. This gives the alcohol its more bitter tastebut thats not the rule for this spirit.
Another large difference between the two is the temperature at which they are served. While you typically refrigerate beer and serve it cold, whiskey does not follow the same practices. Some people argue that whiskey is best enjoyed at room temperature. Others like whiskey on the rocks . However, you would never put ice in beer as it would water down the already mild beverage.
Let’s Talk About Irish Whiskey
Whereas most Scottish whiskey is distilled twice, Irish whiskey goes through three rounds of distillation before it’s bottled. Compared to the Scottish stuff, Irish whiskey uses a lot of barley and doesn’t have that smoky, burnt-rubber taste that you’ll find from the peat that’s in Scotch. Fun fact: legally, Irish whiskey must be aged in Ireland for at least three years in wooden casks to be considered whiskey!
Irish whiskey tastes like: Very, very smooth and less sweet than most American bourbons. Great for sipping.Brands you should know: Jameson, Midleton, Green Spot
Read Also: What’s Tequila Made Out Of
Best Craft: Frey Ranch Bourbon
Courtesy of Total Wine
Region: Nevada | ABV: 45% | Tasting Notes: Caramel, Brown Sugar, Vanilla
Frey Ranch is a newer craft distillery located in Nevada, making grain-to-bottle whiskey on a family farm. The bourbon is made from a mash bill of four grainscorn, wheat, rye, and barleyall grown locally. While some craft bourbon can read a bit young and woody on the palate, this whiskey tastes fully mature and carefully produced. Anyone new to the category who would like to give a craft product a try should sample this bottle.
What Does Rye Whiskey Taste Like Find Out Here
Over the years, one of the most common questions from whiskey enthusiasts is, what does rye whiskey taste like?
The taste of rye whiskey varies considerably, depending on how it was distilled and what type of grain was used to make it. It can be quite spicy, sweet and smooth, or somewhere in-between.
This article will explain what rye whisky is, what it tastes like, how to taste it, and more. Keep reading.
Recommended Reading: Where To Get 1942 Tequila
Best For Sipping: Russells Reserve Single Barrel
Region: Kentucky | ABV: 52% | Tasting Notes: Vanilla, Nutmeg, Oak
I love that Eddie Russell created this despite the fact that his father, Jimmy, whos been distilling and blending Wild Turkey for 60-plus years, hates rye, says Ellenwood. On behalf of all rye drinkers out there, we thank Eddie for rebelling against his father and creating this fine, single barrel rye. At 104 proof, it definitely packs some heat, but thats the essence of rye. Pour it straight and youll get the intensity of the vanilla from its time spent in oak barrels, along with earthy, smoky flavors and a nice, dry finish. Of course, you can also take advantage of the rye’s power by stirring it into a Boulevardier.
Region: Kentucky | ABV: 50% | Tasting Notes: Vanilla, Baking spice, Citrus
When you see bottled-in-bond on a label, it means that the spirit follows the regulations put in place by the Bottled-in-Bond Act of 1897. To be stamped with the honor, whiskeys must be 100 proof, originate from a single U.S. distillery, and be aged for at least four years in a federally bonded warehouse.
What Is White Whiskey Is It Just Moonshine What Is Moonshine
The term “moonshine” is slang for quickly distilled un-aged corn mash and, according to the omnipotent Wikipedia, “is derived from the term ‘moonrakers‘ used for early English smugglers and the clandestine nature of the operation.” So, technically, when you see whiskey labeled “moonshine” in stores, it’s really just white whiskey, because “moonshine” refers to illegal hooch made at home. This stuff is only white because it hasn’t seen the inside of a wooden cask.
White whiskey tastes like: Whiskey-flavored vodkaAnd just so you know, moonshine tastes like: Fire, because it’s almost always at some ridiculously high proof
Don’t Miss: What Mixes Well With Tanqueray Gin
What Is Whiskey/whisky
Whiskey/whisky is a term used to describe a range of alcoholic beverages that come from different varieties of fermented grain.
The most common grains used to make whiskey include barley, malted barley, wheat, corn, rye, and malted rye.
Whiskies that are only made using water and malted barley are called Malt Whiskies, while whiskies that use a combination of grains are called Grain Whiskies.
Sometimes, different types of whiskey will be blended together to add certain flavours to the spirit .
Whiskies are further categorised according to where they are made and how they are made.
Different types of whiskey can have dramatically different flavours and aromas, which is why sampling whiskey has become such a popular hobby.