Skrewball Peanut Butter & Jelly Whiskey Cocktail
May 4, 2021
Make a Skrewball peanut butter & jelly whiskey cocktail for a fun spring or summer drink.
Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey and grape soda goes together likewell, peanut butter & jelly! If you havent tried Skrewball peanut butter whiskey yet, it may surprise you.
I will admit to being a little unsure about it at first too, but after one smooth sip, I was hooked. While its great on the rocks, I prefer cocktails to straight up whiskey.
If you love a good milkshake on a hot summers day, give this decadent drink a try. It is not overwhelming at all, but you definitely get that kick of whiskey.
For our signature cocktail for the holidays this year I made a peanut butter whiskey spiked eggnog.
Now, lets get to this easy recipe so you can give it a try!
Sheep Dog Peanut Butter Whiskey
Sheep Dog Peanut Butter Whiskey is produced in Kentucky and takes pride in its highly natural flavors. It has a light caramel color with vanilla and caramel joining the natural peanut butter on the palate, with subtle whiskey undertones. Leave it in the glass long enough and youll notice some butterscotch coming out.
The drink has a unique, complex, and lingering finish. Youll notice a warm, somewhat dry bite that devolves into a combination of vanilla, caramel, coffee, oak, butterscotch, and whiskey flavors to accompany the ever-present peanut butter.
Because its a bit drier with a stronger whiskey identity, its great for mixing. Youll notice the peanut butter flavor but there are plenty of flavors present in the background to offer balance and complexity. The drier nature does well to balance out a nice chocolate martini, for example.
Spiked Peanut Butter Cider
This is one of many suggestions that come from Skrewball themselves, and its a popular one. Its a nice warm drink, perfect for a rainy night in or a cold winter evening. Its simple all you must do is add one and a half ounces of your chosen peanut butter whiskey to four ounces of hot apple cider.
For some extra warmth garnish with a cinnamon stick.
You can scale the recipe to create as many servings as you need. Its a tasty, simple drink to share at any kind of gathering, especially in the colder weather.
You May Like: Jello Shots With Pinnacle Whipped Vodka
Screwball Whiskey Milkshake Recipe
Are you a big fan of coffee? Want to explore its taste by adding it into whiskey? Then make this one. Take some scoops of coffee ice cream, add some peanut butter whiskey and blend them. The milkshake is ready. Using whipped cream, chocolate syrup, milk for garnishing is your choice. Want to see if it goes well with any other flavor? Then change the ice cream flavor you have used.
Do let us know what other flavors made it tastier.
What Are The Top 5 Whiskeys
Here are some of the best whiskeys you can get your hands on now.
- Best Overall: Four Roses Single Barrel.
- Best Rye: Pikesville Straight Rye.
- Best Irish: Redbreast 12 Year Old.
- Best Scotch: The Balvenie DoubleWood.
- Best Peated Scotch: Bowmore 12 Year Old.
- Best Japanese: Hakushu 12 Year Old.
Don’t Miss: Is Jim Beam Good Whiskey
Drunken Peanut Butter Rum Punch
The Drunken peanut butter rum punch is a variation on the more traditional Whiskey Ginger that’s been given this name because of its unique and highly flavorful combination of ingredients. It contains both yellow or light brown sugar as well as dark corn syrup–these two sweeteners are mixed together with Guinness beer, ginger ale , and American whiskey to make it taste delicious!
Mix ½ cup each brown sugar, white sugar, corn syrup in a bowl until they’re evenly distributed pour in ¾ cup chilled Guinness beer and cups chilled ginger ale/seltzer water add one tablespoon vanilla extract then mix everything together again. You’ll also want to use about three tablespoons of bourbon whiskey and one tablespoon of dark rum.
Pour the mixture into a large bowl, then add ice cubes until it’s about ¾ full top off with more beer–either Guinness or any other type you prefer . You can garnish this drink by pouring some whipped cream on top and adding in two tablespoons of chocolate syrup to give it an extra dose of sweetness if desired. However, these aren’t necessary since there are plenty of natural sweeteners already included so go ahead and enjoy!
Is There Peanut Butter In Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey
Made using real peanuts, Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey is as crazy as it sounds. Its the answer of why not when someone asks, why? With its surprising sweetness, smooth finish, and obvious peanut butter flavor, this American whiskey proudly bucks convention as the black sheep of the whiskey aisle.
Recommended Reading: What Is The Strongest Tequila
Ole Smokey Peanut Butter Whiskey
Ole Smokey is most well-known for its vast collection of 27 flavored moonshines and even more flavored whiskies. They make their whiskey using standard, traditional methods before pairing it with a combination of classic and bold/innovative flavors.
Their Peanut Butter Whiskey is among the most popular. Others include blackberry, moonshine, apple pie, moonshine cherries, and more.
Their peanut butter expression really focuses on the peanut butter. Creamy peanut butter dominates the nose and peanut butter is strongest on the palate as well. Its a simple flavor profile, well-complimented by Ole Smokeys classic, smooth whiskey.
Peanut Butter Whiskey Milkshake
Have you ever thought of mixing whiskey to make a milkshake? This combination seems interesting and amazing.
The ingredients to take are:
- 4 oz Screwball peanut butter whiskey
- 25 oz of milk
- Peanut butter cups
Directions to follow
Drizzle chocolate syrup on a cold milkshake glass and blend it well. Blend milk, ice-cream, and whiskey together in equal amounts. Pour the mixture into the glass and stir it well. You can also make whipped cream out of it.
You May Like: Does Whole Foods Sell Vodka
Peanut Butter And Egg White Cocktail
This recipe is perfect for those who are on a low calorie diet or have to watch their figure and enjoy vodka. It starts by putting in some ice cubes, egg whites along with one cup of sugar-free vanilla flavored yogurt after this has been blended together then you’ll need diced cucumber as well as peanut butter–the amount needed will depend on how strong you want the flavor so try adding about two tablespoons first before deciding if it needs more!
Peanut Butter Whiskey Is The Most Polarizing Pairing Yet Or Is It
Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey is exactly what it sounds like: a PB-flavored libation, and not, unfortunately, something you can smush between two pieces of bread with some jelly on top.
According to an email from the brand, the polarizing peanut-y beverage is made in a lab to perfect the almost impossible peanut butter flavor, which is made from real, natural peanuts. After launching the whiskey in San Diego in 2018, the beverage makers teamed up with a spirits company to expand distribution nationwide.
Its great news for peanut butter lovers and terrible news for whiskey purists. But, before we judge a book by its nutty-sounding cover, whiskey and peanut butter enthusiasts alike at HuffPost thought it only proper to taste it for ourselves.
Some were surprised to find out they actually gasp liked it, some had trouble finding a peanut butter flavor at all, and more than one person pointed out that if nothing else, it would make for a pretty stellar ice cream pairing. The best assessment of all, though, was inspired by the smell alone.
The scent is both attractive and repulsive at the same time, one colleague said. Isnt that what a smell should be?
Take a look at HuffPosters reviews below, and head to Skrewball to find out where you can purchase the whiskey if youre feeling nutty enough to try it yourself.
Recommended Reading: What To Drink With 1800 Tequila Silver
Peanut Butter And Jelly
Looking for a unique peanut butter whiskey drink? Try the Peanut Butter and Jelly, a quirky sweet tart cocktail made with Skrewball peanut butter and cranberry juice. This unlikely combination makes the cocktail version of your favorite childhood sandwich! We took inspiration from the co-founder of Skrewball herself, Brittany Yeng, who recommends pairing this flavored whiskey with cranberry to cut the sweetness.
Ingredients: Skrewball peanut butter whiskey, cranberry juice, Cointreau
Peanut Butter Whiskey Drinks
Many people wonder, what can I make with peanut butter whiskey?.
There are less peanut butter whiskey recipes compared to a traditional liquor, like say, vodka or tequila.
The most common peanut butter whiskey drink recipes feature some form of a play on peanut butter and jelly.
While that may satisfy some, we much prefer a more decadent option, thus, the peanut butter cup martini was born.
You May Like: Can You Mix Ginger Ale And Whiskey
Peanut Butter Whiskey Cocktail
This peanut butter whiskey cocktail needs to be your new fall libation.
Peanut butter whiskey is a new trend in the world of cocktails.
With many brands on shelves, what kind of delicious cocktail can you make?
We whipped up a chocolate peanut butter martini to try it out and it tastes like an alcoholic version of your favorite candy bar!
This sweet martini recipe will also win over hearts with its rich flavor and creamy texture.
Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey Review And Recipes
Youd be hard-pressed to find anyone who doesnt love peanut butter and whiskey separately, of course. Theyre delectable, life-affirming treats that taste best first thing in the morning with breakfast. But, peanut butter whiskey seems like the answer to a question no one was asking. Regardless, Skrewballs Peanut Butter Whiskey has answered that question.
The self-described worlds first peanut butter whiskey is purportedly the first and only such whiskey on the market. Skrewball is taking a bold stance that their liquid novelty is not only good as a flavoring agent, but that it stands confidently on its own: as a shot, on the rocks, or neat. Its a tall promise. Intense flavoring works in vodkas and rums. However, flavored whiskey just as with, say, flavored tequila is a whole other animal.
After a neat sampling, our first impressions were mixed. The nose is earthy and slightly dusty, reminiscent of natural peanut butter. The taste is another matter entirely. The whiskey takes a backseat to the peanut butter notes, which are strong, rich, and sweet, almost cloying. This is a love-it-or-hate-it liquor.
For serious peanut butter fans who like their cocktails on the syrupy, dessert-like side, it seems a perfect fit. Skrewball gets this, which is why their lineup of recipes includes peanut-butter-forward cocktails like the Skrew Putin .
Recommended Reading: Jim Beam Honey Mixers
How To Make This Into A Peanut Butter And Jelly Shot:
This whiskey drink is technically too large to be a shot as the recipe is written.
We enjoy it for sipping. the mingled flavors are just too good to gulp In my opinion. But if you want to throw it back. Make a shot.
To make this a shot just cut the recipe down by half. Then it will fit in your 1 1/2 oz. shot glass.
Sqqrl Peanut Butter Whiskey
SQQRL Peanut Butter Whiskey is made by prominent whiskey producer Jim Beam so you can have confidence in its quality despite its slightly unconventional nature. This is a good option for those who are skeptical of this novel new category of whiskey but still want to try it.
Its a beautiful amber color with light golden hues with a strong aroma of freshly roasted peanuts. This is balanced nicely with sweet notes of butterscotch and chocolate.
The palate is similar, opening with strong, smooth peanut butter and a touch of chocolate. The finish is long with more roasted peanuts and sweet, lingering butterscotch.
Also Check: How Many Carbs Does Flavored Vodka Have
Peanut Butter And Chile Vodka Cocktail
This drink recipe is perfect for those who enjoy spicy food or want to add a little complexity into their lives. It starts by combining vodka , frozen banana slices, and peanut butter in a blender after this has been blended together then you’ll need one teaspoon of chile powder as well as some ice cubes for it to go down smoothly.
Bird Dog Peanut Butter Whiskey
Bird Dog Peanut Butter Whiskey is a surprisingly affordable bottle for the strength and quality youre getting. It offers a solid, varied flavor profile without veering too far away from peanut butter. Many say it rivals the original Skrewball quite well.
The nose offers warm peanuts with a hint of wood and char. The palate brings aromatic notes of vanilla and sweet caramel in the background of smooth peanut butter flavors. The finish is slow and warm with more peanuts and a hint of sweet caramel at the very end.
The flavor is smooth and bold enough to sip neat while also pairing quite well in many fun cocktails. Its bottled at 80 proof which is a little more than most others of its kind. The additional alcohol balances the sweetness just a little without making it too harsh by any means.
Don’t Miss: Whole Foods Liquor
Highballs And Tall Cocktails
PB& J Highball: Add 1.5 ounces of pb whiskey to a tall glass, fill with ice, and top with strawberry seltzer water.
Fluffernutter Highball: Add 1 ounce of peanut butter whiskey and 1 ounce of marshmallow vodka to a highball glass. Fill with ice and top with club soda or unflavored seltzer water. Garnish with marshmallows.
Peanut Butter Whiskey Sour: Make a classic sour with 1 oz peanut butter liqueur, 1 oz bourbon, 1 oz lemon juice and ½ oz simple syrup. Shake together and strain into a rocks glass over ice.
What Is Good To Mix With Skrewball Whiskey
This bottle wont go to waste with so many fun Skrewball drinks you can make. In fact, I bet youll be buying a new bottle before you know it. Skrewball whiskey is good with a variety of mixers because there are so many mixers for delicious peanut butter whiskey drinks.
Here are some perfect mixers to make Skrewball peanut butter whiskey drinks:
- Grape Flavored Sodas
Peanut Butter White Russian decadent peanut butter whiskey with Kahlua and cream.
Don’t Miss: Bacardi 151 Discontinued
It Tastes Like Caramel Popcorn Melted Down Into A Drink
I know this is supposed to be peanut butter. However, it tastes like caramel popcorn melted down into a drink in the best possible way. I loathe whiskey, so I was scared, but it makes it palatable.
Drinking this makes me feel like Im in Harry Potter. Partially because its buttery, sweet and delicious, like how butterbeer would taste. Probably more so because I keep taking sips of it and its making me buzzed to the point where Im about to convince myself Im an actual wizard.
My Whole Tongue Feels Like Its Being Coated With Butter
It smells amazing, first of all. A lot like peanut butter. But it tastes more like caramel corn to me than peanut butter. My whole tongue feels like its being coated with butter, and its super sweet. And honestly, Im not mad about either of those things.
I dont know if I would drink this regularly, but every once in a while when I have both a whiskey and a sugar craving, this could do the trick.
Also Check: Why Did They Discontinue Bacardi 151
Easy Screwball Drink / Skrewball Whiskey Recipes
The Screwball Drink is delicious and fruity with a nice peanut butter taste. The key ingredient is Skrewball, the new kid on the whisky block with its unexpected infusion of peanuts. Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey combines two classics for distinctive flavor and out-of-the-box cocktail recipes.
With peanut butter-flavored whisky,you can create all kinds of tasty mixes to satisfy your sweet tooth. Thiswhisky is often combined with ingredients like chocolate or fruity liqueur fora drink thats part dessert, part cocktail.
Im A Little Embarrassed I Like This So Much
This coats my tongue the way a Starbucks caramel syrup does, and though its wildly sweet for a whiskey, its warm and … not unpleasant? Im getting butterscotch, caramel corn and a little punch of coffee at the end but no peanut butter flavor, only aroma .
Theres no doubt its a dessert whiskey I imagine it being the perfect melting place for a scoop of vanilla ice cream. As a major whiskey/bourbon drinker, Im a little embarrassed I like this so much.
Read Also: Bacardi Rum Alcohol Content
What Is The Best Flavored Whiskey
Here are the best flavored whiskeys.
- Best Overall: Knob Creek Smoked Maple Bourbon Whiskey.
- Best Spicy: George Dickel Tabasco Barrel Finish Whisky.
- Best Peanut Butter: Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey.
- Best Cinnamon: Jim Beam Bourbon Kentucky Fire Whiskey.
- Best Vanilla: Crown Royal Canadian Vanilla Whisky.
Oatmeal Cookies And White Whiskey
Top pick: High West Silver Whiskey Western Oat Without barrel aging to add other flavors, the grains play a prominent role in a white whiskey, making it a natural fit with the grainy flavors of a sweet oatmeal cookie. Any white whiskey will work well, though its hard to resist the obvious continuity of pairing this oat-based whiskey from High West.
Read Also: Chattanooga Whiskey Where To Buy