Flavor Variations For Hot Buttered Rum:
Use my recipe as a guide, adapting it to suit your taste. Feel free to play around with the portions of water and rum to make it stronger. You can also tweak the flavorings by doing any of the following:
- Spices: This recipe uses cinnamon , along with a bit of nutmeg and cloves. You can also use ginger, allspice, or apple/pumpkin pie spice . Increase or decrease the different spices to get your perfect blend.
- Orange: Add some finely grated orange zest into the butter mixture for an underlying citrus flavor. You can also garnish each drink with a piece of thinly sliced orange.
- Apple cider: Swap some of the hot water for hot apple cider. This will make a sweeter apple-flavored cocktail. You can also garnish each drink with a thinly sliced apple.
- Honey: In addition to sweetening this drink with brown sugar, I also add maple syrup. Feel free to swap the syrup for honey if that is a flavor youd prefer.
NEVER MISS A RECIPE! to our free EMAIL LIST LIKE us on Follow on
How To Store Your Hot Buttered Rum Mix
One of the great things about this drink mix is that it will keep in the freezer for 3 months.
Since there are only three of us around for the holidays this year, Im happy to have the makings for a hot, holiday beverage available on an as-needed basis. Next year, when I hope to be entertaining again, Ill probably double the recipe to serve at parties.
My Easy Hot Buttered Rum is so simple to make and enjoy at home! Try my recipe for winters favorite beverage get ready to celebrate with a hot, delicious mug of holiday cheer!
Coziest Gift Ever: Hot Buttered Rum Mix
A cup of hot buttered rum tastes like the holidays, and the cozy, spiced flavors are warming in more ways than one. What better edible gift to lead us into the weekend than a batch of homemade hot buttered rum mix? This mix is super-easy to make en masse then divvy up into small jars for all your festive friends.
To make the gift even more special, buy the recipient a nice bottle of dark rum to complete the cocktail. Be sure to include a recipe card with instructions on how to mix up a cup
Youll need just 5 ingredients and a few spices to make this easy coffee cocktail!
- Unsalted butter I recommend using a high quality, extra creamy butter for this recipe.
- Dark brown sugar For rich, flavorful sweetness.
- Spices Cinnamon, cardamom, nutmeg, and ground cloves, as well as a pinch of kosher salt.
- Black strap rum My preferred rum for hot buttered rum is Cruzan® Black Strap Rum.
- Brewed coffee Make sure the coffee is very hot for this recipe. I prefer to use a darker, full-bodied coffee here.
- Creamor half & half Use whatever you prefer.
- Whipped cream + cinnamon For garnish!
You May Like: Who Owns Patron Tequila Paul Mitchell
How To Make Hot Buttered Rum From Scratch
Learn how to make hot buttered rum with this quick and easy recipe.
Hot buttered rum is a hot alcoholic drink made with boiling water, butter, sugar, spices, and alcohol . In researching hot buttered rum recipes, I noticed a few were ice cream-based, which seems really odd to me. This is a recipe for hot buttered rum from scratch from a butter batter, not ice cream.
What Rum Goes Best With Apple Cider
What is the Best Rum to Put in Apple Cider? Sailor Jerry Spiced Rum has bold flavors of cloves and cinnamon spice finished with vanilla and oak and is light on sweetness. At times, you can pick up hints of toffee and caramel, which would be perfect with hot apple cider.
Whats the best alcohol to mix with apple cider?
What alcohol is good with apple cider? Apple cider pairs really well with dark spirits, like rum, whiskey, bourbon, and brandy. However, you can also combine it with other spirits, liked Vodka or even Mezcal or Tequila.
What is a good liquor to put in hot cider?
Rum or bourbon are the best choices. Any type of rum works: white rum, aged rum, or dark rum . Any type of bourbon works as well! The rum melds more seamlessly into the flavor of cider, making it our top choice.
What alcohol goes well with spiced cider?
What Do You Spike Cider With? We recommend spiking apple cider with either whiskey or rum. Whiskey will give your spiked cider a spicier warm taste, while rum will give it a sweeter taste. For a combination of sweet and spicy, we recommend Fireball or another cinnamon whiskey.
What kind of alcohol can you mix with apple cider?
How do you spike cider?
How Do You Make Mulled Hot Apple Cider?
Read Also: How Many Carbs In Peach Vodka
Whats The Best Rum To Use
Any dark or spiced rum will work to make this Christmas cocktail. Spiced rum is typically dark rum that has been flavored with caramel and other spices. I prefer dark rum because you have more control over the spices added, but a quality spiced rum works well too. I recommend a mid-range rum not the cheapest, but you definitely dont need the most expensive either.
What Is Hot Buttered Rum
If youve never heard of it before, buttered rum is a hot drink made with butter, brown sugar, spices, water, and rum . Its often topped with a foamy cap of lightly sweetened whipped cream, which, Im sure I dont have to tell you, is incredibly delicious.
There can be all sorts of variations on this theme, which I talk more about below, but in a nutshell, this hot toddy is rich, buttery, very cinnamon-y, and a little creamy, with a boozy kick.
Its perfect for a cold night, especially if youre sick or feeling restless and unable to sleep.
Don’t Miss: What Is Pinnacle Whipped Vodka
What To Serve With Hot Buttered Rum
There are several desserts and snacks that pair well with a hot toddy. Try one of these:
- Cheese: Our baked brie is an amazing choice, but these beautiful whipped brie stuffed strawberries are also a great pick!
- Gingerbread: This spicy type of cookie is even delicious dunked in your buttered rum. Try my soft gingerbread cookies, gingersnap cookies, or my molasses cookies.
- Creme Brulee: Definitely a great pairing, try my espresso creme brulee at home!
- Cheesecake: The creamy texture and crumbly crust of a cheesecake goes great with buttered rum. Try my mini turtle cheesecakes, chocolate cheesecake brownies, or my classic cheesecake for dessert.
Ps Hot Buttered Rum Batter Is The Gift That Keeps On Giving
Not only is this easy hot buttered rum recipe handy for mixing up at home, the frozen batter make a great gift, too! Freeze a batch of batter and gift it along with a little recipe card explaining how to make hot buttered rum. If youre feeling extra generous, gift the batter along with a bottle of dark rum and a festive mug.
Read Also: Is Vodka Good For Keto
Buttered Rum Done Right
Although no one would think of adding olive oil to champagne, Curtis maintained that when done properly, hot buttered rum is the absolute comfort food in a mug. The key, he said is to make a thick batter consisting of softened butter, brown and white sugar, spices, and softened vanilla ice cream.
This batter is placed in a mug along with rum and boiling water is stirred in. According to Curtis, the ice cream prevents the odious slick of grease from forming on the drinks surface.
Recommended Reading: Pinnacle Whip Cream Vodka Calories
Not Everyone Approved Of Adding Butter
Hot buttered rum may sound inviting, but the drink did have its detractors, according to Wayne Curtis, who wrote And a Bottle of Rum: A History of the New World in Ten Cocktails. Curtis quotes David Embury, author of The Fine Art of Mixing Drinks, a classic cocktail book that was published in 1948, as follows:
The lump of butter is the final insult. It blends with the hot rum just about as satisfactorily as warm olive oil blends with champagne!
Also Check: How Do You Make An Old Fashioned Whiskey Drink
Old Fashioned Hot Buttered Rum
The classic hot buttered rum recipe comes together pretty quickly it’ll be in your hands before you’ve even finished removing your winter layers.
- 2 teaspoons packed brown sugar
- 1 tablespoon melted unsalted butter
- 1 dash pure vanilla extract
- Hot water to top off
- Whipped cream or cinnamon stick for garnish
How To Make Hot Buttered Rum
how to make Hot Buttered Rum
Not sure how to make Hot Buttered Rum? No worries … just follow these few simple steps. It’s easy to make your mugful!
The batter may be used immediately, or it can be stored in the refrigerator to be used a little at a time when you’d like.
Don’t Miss: How To Make Strawberry Vodka Lemonade
Variations On Hot Buttered Rum
You can feel free to make this recipe your own by adding or subbing any of your favorite spices.
- Chinese 5-spice Powder
- Ground Ginger
You could also add a little vanilla or almond extract, to bring out the sweetness.
Another option is to use something other than water to make your toddy. I really love this with hot tea, apple cider, or even orange juice.
And if youd like to make a non-alcoholic version, its as simple as leaving the rum out.
What Is The Best Rum For Hot Buttered Rum
Once the homemade hot buttered rum mix is ready, its time to think about the rum. I recommend using dark rum in this recipe for its bolder flavor. Plantation is a great all-around, price-conscious rum option if youre looking for a specific brand.
Of course, it all comes down to what you like to drink.
If youre a lover of spice, you might want to go with spiced rum for even more spice flavor throughout the drink.
Read Also: How To Drink Whiskey Sour
What Is A Hot Buttered Rum
This hot drink apparently was popular during Colonial times. It is a pretty simple combination of brown sugar, white sugar, winter spices, butter, and rum. The spices include nutmeg, allspice, and cinnamon. These were all ingredients easily found in that time era.
It sounds weird to put butter in a drink, but its delicious! It makes the cocktail super creamy. You can even make a kid-friendly version of this drink for decorating the tree by leaving out the rum. Its the perfect winter drink for everyone in the house.
Hot Buttered Rum For A Crowd
Its pretty much a guarantee that you will find some hot buttered rum batter in my freezer throughout the winter because theres nothing better than a hot, spiced, and smooth cocktail to warm you up when its chilly outside. Plus, as a quintessential holiday drink, this one is a must for entertaining!
As it makes enough batter for about 50 drinks, this recipe is my go-to for winter gatherings. If 50 drinks sounds like a lot and you dont have any parties on the schedule, dont worry the batter freezes super well for 3 months or more and you can easily prepare just one or two drinks at a time.
So what does hot buttered rum taste like? Not like eating a stick of butter! Hot buttered rum is smooth and creamy with buttery undertones, but vanilla and the warm apple pie spices balance out the butter. Its a bit like sipping on a warm apple fritter donut. Hot buttered rum has actually been around since the colonial times, though I would wager that it wasnt quite as flavorful or creamy as this modern version!
Also Check: What Whiskey Stones Are Best
Why Do People Drink Hot Buttered Rum During The Holidays
Its warm, boozy, and offers the optional comforting warmth of baking spices, like cinnamon, cloves, allspice, and nutmeg, all of which are often used in winter-friendly recipes. It also doesnt hurt that National Hot Buttered Rum Day is celebrated on January 17, giving Hot Buttered Rum fans the excuse to continue enjoying the boozy drink well into the new year.
Page : A Recipe For The Rum Toddy
This is Page 3 of a three-page recipe article. Click on the black links below to visit other pages.
Hot Buttered Rum History / Hot Toddy History
A cocktail made with boiling water, sugar and spices is traditionally referred to as a “toddy,” and made with whiskey or sherry. Warm alcoholic beverages such as glogg, mulled wine and toddies originated in Northern Europe, where beer, cider, wine and spirits were mulled with sugar and spices to add some cheer to cold winter days.
Hot buttered rum is a toddy . Toddies can be made of any spiritbourbon, brandy, tequila, Scotch and other whiskeys are popular.
Hot buttered rum was a favorite in Colonial America. Rum is a New World spirit, made of molasses, a by-product of sugar refining. Distilleries in the Colonies were making rum from the molasses by the 1650s, and hot buttered rum joined the toddies and nogs of English tradition .
Hot buttered rum is traditionally made with dark rum, which has been aged in oak barrels to develop a deeper, molasses flavor. You can use light rum or spiced rum for a milder or spicier flavor, respectively. Dark rums can also be drunk straight.
You may see photos of, or recipes for, creamy toddies, which add cream or ice cream to the basic recipe. These are new interpretations, not traditional toddies, which were not cream beverages.
Also Check: What To Mix With Orange Vodka
Hot Buttered Rum Recipe: Different Ways To Make Deliciousness
Allison is a bartender & mixologist who served drinks in Boston & New Hampshire, creating craft cocktails. She also served as a cocktails writer and editor for Casual Mixologist.
Learn More About LoveToKnow’s Editorial Policies.
Warm drinks add a cozy layer to cold days or even those first few cooler days of fall. Hot buttered rum is a great way to bring a balmy mood to a gray or drizzly day, and with the availability of modifications, there’s a hot buttered rum for everyone. So next time you’re settling in as the cold weather settles in around you, consider trying out a hot buttered rum recipe.
Why This Recipe Works:
- This recipe whips up really quick which is why we love it so much.
- It has a delicious mix of flavors from apple cider to rum to butter and brown sugar.
- You can easily double or triple this drink too make more for parties.
Hot Buttered Rum is one of those drinks that once September hits, we make them over and over again. They are just so good and so simple to make.
Honestly I just cant get over the flavors of this recipe, all of them combined will literally just melt in your mouth, its smooth with sweetness which is the kind of drink I like.
Read Also: How To Mix Rum And Coke
We Cant Promise Snow But A Cup Of Cheer Oh Yeah Were All Over That
Snow is falling, a cozy fire is crackling, and Netflix is all queued up. But waitmy hands are empty. They need to be cupped around a mug of something hot and boozy, stat! Hot buttered rum gives Mulled Wine a run for its money as the most classic winter warmer. Warmly spiced and delightfully warming, they each have their place. A big simmering pot of mulled wine is great for a party, while hot buttered rum is ideal for quiet nights in. Mix up a batch of this hot buttered rum batterenough for 24 servingspop it in the freezer. Whether youre mixing up a few mugs to serve as a nightcap after an intimate dinner party or whisking up a cocktail for one, having a batch of this buttered rum batter in the freezer means youll have a whole seasons worth of everyones favorite warm, boozy cocktail right at your fingertips.
Dont Miss: Good Things To Mix With Crown Apple
How To Make Hot Buttered Rum Mix
The best part about making hot buttered rum is that the base is easily made into a mix. All you need to make the drink is the pre-made mix, butter, water, and rum. Its as easy as whipping up a cup of hot cocoa. Store the hot buttered rum mix in a mason jar.
Measure out the dry ingredients and place them in a mason jar. Put the lid on tight and shake the jar to combine the ingredients. Store in a cool dry place.
You May Like: Svedka Seltzer 8%
Read Also: What Is The Most Expensive Vodka
Rum Or None The Choice Is Yours
Hot Buttered Rum is a wonderful adult beverage that can be made with any kind of rum. Dark rum, light rum, or spiced rum will all make for a delicious drink.
But if you dont drink alcohol or just dont like rum, its easy to make a non-alcoholic version of this cocktail. Simply replace the rum with an equal amount of hot cider. While you can use hot water in the non-alcoholic version, I really recommend using cider instead.