Best Peanut Butter Whiskey Brands
Last Updated on July 21, 2022 by Lydia Martin
Peanut butter and whiskey are certainly not something you thought would taste good together. However, back in 2018, this was proven untrue, and the brands just never stopped making their versions. But which ones are worth drinking?
Lets find out the best peanut butter whiskey brands and what sets them apart.
Ole Smoky Peanut Butter Whiskey
Ole Smoky is known for its moonshine, producing other spirits before venturing to flavored whiskies. They use a 2-year-old corn whiskey as the base. It has a smooth texture with bursting flavors of buttered popcorn, licorice, and honey.
The peanut butter kick is profound, from the nose to the palate. You can treat this as a straight bourbon whiskey since this is best drank straight or on the rocks. It is one of the best peanut butter-flavored bottles, sold for roughly $21.
Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey
URL Copied to your Clipboard
On one side, you have good ol whiskey – a bold, loud, and strong partner-in-crime who exudes confidence. On the other, we have peanut butter – a rich, smooth, and irresistible spread thats as dependable as they come for all your late night cravings. Little did you know, these two blend together quite phenomenally. In fact, they go together so well, they make PB& J jealous. Its nearly impossible to just have one of this delicious treat. But we have to warn you – a night with Skrewball is bound to get a little nutty.
Added to Cart!
What Is Peanut Butter Whiskey
Peanut butter whiskey is a blended drink that combines the peanut butter flavor and bourbon. These two ingredients are often mixed together in a blender or shaker with ice before being strained into a glass, although sometimes other liquors can be added to this mixture. Some common variations on peanut butter whiskey cocktails include adding cream to make them more creamy-tasting or using flavored whiskeys for an extra layer of flavor.
There is also a popular peanut butter whiskey brand named Skrewball whiskey, which is based in Ocean Beach, San Diego, California and was started by âblack sheepâ husband and wife, Steven Yeng and Brittany Merrill Yeng. Itâs arguable the best flavored whiskey in the peanut butter flavored whiskey category.
In addition to serving as a tasty and popular drink, peanut butter whiskey has also been used as a sauce for desserts â especially those that call for chocolate or vanilla ice cream.
Also Check: Is Bombay Sapphire Gin Made With Juniper Berries
Peanut Butter Chocolate Old Fashioned
Anything combining peanut butter and chocolate is a winning combination for me. This Peanut Butter Chocolate Old Fashioned cocktail keeps the bourbon at the forefront with the bulk of the base spirit. However, if you prefer, you can split the difference between the pb whiskey and the bourbon for a sweeter, more indulgent cocktail.
Donât Miss: Jim Beam Honey Whiskey Recipe
Don’t Miss: What Can You Make With White Rum
What Does Peanut Butter Whiskey Taste Like
Peanut butter has a thick, sticky texture. It tastes very sweet, with a strong peanut finish and notes of caramel, coffee and vanilla. Honestly, its more like drinking Baileys than bourbon! In fact, dont expect it to taste much like whiskey at all. Its more like drinking a liquid peanut butter cup, with a hint of that whiskey bite.
How much alcohol is in Skrewball peanut butter whiskey? It is 35% ABV . It has a high alcohol content thats similar to whiskey, which weighs in at 40%. Technically whiskey is supposed to be bottled at no less than 80 proof , so some may claim this product is not whiskey.
Are there any Skrewball substitutes? There are several brands of peanut butter whiskey on the market. Skrewball is the original, and considered by many to be the best brand in its category. But you can try Skatterbrain, PB & W, Sheepdog, Ole Smokey, and Shepherds PNutty.
What Our Customers Are Saying
License #195307 Maple Ridge Liquor Store, #194796 Port Moody Liquor Store, #195415 Langley Liquor Warehouse, #192410 Kanaka Creek Liquor Store, #195230 Lougheed Liquor Store.
Also Check: Svedka Blue Raspberry Vodka Carbs
Also Check: What Is The Best Whiskey In The World
Hard Truth Peanut Butter Whiskey
Hard Truth Peanut Butter whiskey is another best peanut butter whiskey. It is straight bourbon-based with a dark-gold hue made by Hard Truth Distilling Company. Compared to other peanut butter whiskey brands, this bottle offers more complexity with flavor.
It has clear oaky notes with an equally balanced sweet and salty taste. It is infused with deep-roasted peanuts that provide a pleasant aftertaste. This flavorful whiskey from the Hard Truth distillery is sold at around $32 per 750 ml.
Skatterbrain Peanut Butter Whiskey
Skatterbrain is a Canadian whiskey base flavored drink from Universal Brands in Minnesota. It became available to the public in 2020. The packaging of this flavored whiskey is very similar to Skrewbal. Flavor-wise, it has vanilla notes, caramel, and butterscotch taste on top of the peanut butter.
One thing noticeable is that the sweetness and the peanut butter whiskey taste are artificial. They do not claim that they are using natural flavors anyway. A 750 ml bottle is sold for roughly $19.
Read Also: Does Coconut Rum Have Coconut In It
Spiked Peanut Butter Cider
Take classic apple cider to the next level with Skrewball. Whether your serving apple cider for your next fall bash or drinking it curled up by the fire, this cocktail will satisfy anyones fall cravings for peanut butter and apples, all made in a toasty adult drink.
- 1.5 oz. Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey
- 4 oz hot apple cider
Build all the ingredients in a heated mug and garnish with fresh apple slices and a cinnamon stick.
Very Small Batch Spirits
Every batch of our signature product is handcrafted with Michigan Winter Wheat. To ensure the highest quality possible, batches are triple-distilled and continuously taste-tested. Perfect for fireside sipping or crafting adventurous cocktails.2013 Silver Medal winner from The Beverage Tasting Institute
We hunted down this centuries-old recipe of juniper berries, coriander, licorice root, bitter orange peel and numerous other botanicals. To create this complex, yet balanced gin the ingredients are steeped in 190 proof spirits and slowly distilled. Ideal for crafting full-flavor martinis, aromatic gin and tonics or just sipping slowly on the rocks.
Our Bacon Flavored Vodka is like mans best friendonly for Bloody Marys. Created in 2012, we were the first distillery to offer this delicious and savory, flavored vodka. Taste it for yourself and see why it has become one of our most popular spirits.
Unleash a truly unique flavor. Our Raspberry Flavored Vodka features a crisp, and floral taste with just a hint of sweetness. Its perfect for shaking up a Raspberry Martini or creating new, fruity summer cocktails.
In their own way, pirates were explorersand in the 1800s a few of them even sailed the Great Lakes. As a tribute to their sense of adventure, we crafted this light, full-flavored Rum from 100% sugar cane. Mix with your favorite soda or punch and let the good times sail.
Don’t Miss: Don Julio Tequila Total Wine
Reviewers Say It Really Tastes Like Peanut Butter
We all love Reeses peanut butter cups. Its a factaccording to this research, theyre one of Americas most popular types of Halloween candy. Whats not to love? You know peanut butter and chocolate are a classic combo.
The one thing we hadnt thought of adding peanut butter to is alcohol. Not that it wouldnt be good, but like, how could that even be done? Thankfully, Skrewball Whiskey Company found a way and we cant wait to try peanut butter whiskey.
Rams Point Peanut Butter Whiskey
Rams Point Peanut Butter whiskey is from Sazerac, the reputed spirit manufacturer since 1869. The peanut butter taste is very similar to Reeses Peanut butter cup, even with the smell, with a slight whiff of chocolate. The sweet-salty taste is there but more on the sweet side.
This peanut butter-flavored whiskey also has a medium oak appearance and leaves a bit of a bitter finish. You can have a delicious shot of this variant, but it would be best to have it chilled or iced. Each 750 ml is sold for roughly $17.
Don’t Miss: Where To Buy Tin Cup Whiskey
Why We Like It
Skrewball peanut butter whiskey has its fans and haters. Our honest opinion? Its a bit sweet for our tastes. We went in thinking it would taste like whiskey with a hint of peanut on the finish. But its bold and sweet: more like a peanut butter cup liqueur with its creamy, sweet finish.
But, how you mix it matters! We were able to mix up a few drinks with Skrewball that balanced flavors using tart, bubbly, or bitter mixers. Its great with cranberry juice or orange juice, a few shakes of cocktail bitters, or coffee. Just dont mix it with Baileys or make it into a White Russian.
Also Check: What Mixes With Vodka Well
Pb& w Peanut Butter Whiskey
PB& W Peanut Butter whiskey is from Old Elk distillery, which also produces Dry Town gin and bourbon whiskey. However, the distillery never disclosed whether they are using their premium whiskey as the base for this peanut butter-flavored whiskey.
This bottle is one of the early competitors of Skrewball Peanut Butter whiskey. It has a deep salted peanut butter flavor with notes of caramel and vanilla with a hint of apple. The viscosity of the liquid is not too much. Each 750 ml bottle is roughly $26.
Read Also: Where Can I Buy Redbreast Whiskey
What Are Some Popular Brands Of Peanut Butter Whiskey
If you’re having trouble picking a brand, the original, Skrewball, may be a good place to start, but considering peanut butter whiskey is one of the most popular liquors in the U.S., it seems you can’t go wrong with whatever you choose. According to Bartendr, Sheep Dog Peanut Butter Whiskey, Sqrrl Peanut Butter Whiskey, Ole Smoky Peanut Butter Whiskey, Hard Truth Peanut Butter Whiskey, and Skatterbrain Peanut Butter Whiskey are six of the best.
In addition, if you happen to be allergic to peanuts and still want to see what the hype is all about, Drug Genius confirms that Sqrrl Peanut Butter Whiskey is allergen-free, as is Sheep Dog’s, according to Hunter and Bligh. Really there’s no excuse not to try it.
Drunken Peanut Butter Vodka Shot
This recipe is very simple that doesnât take hours to make but packs quite a punch. It starts by putting peanut butter in the bottom of an empty shot glass and then pouring vodka on topâthe amount needed will depend on how strong you want it so start with about one tablespoon before deciding if more is needed after this has been poured out, then stir together gently to create your drink for consumption!
Read Also: What Goes Good With Vodka
There Is Now Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey Ice Cream
A year or so ago I had a buddy introduce me to Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey. Sounded awful, tasted amazing! So when I saw someone on social media talking about Skrewball ice cream, I had to find out more.
We partnered with Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey to bring you an adult take on two favorite childhood snacks! This limited edition flavor features our signature creamy vanilla ice cream base infused with Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey and a chocolate fudge swirl. Pack contains four 16oz pints of ice cream.
All flavors contain up to 5% alcohol by volume and can only be consumed by those 21 and over. Please note that an adult signature is required upon delivery. If you are sending our boozy ice cream as a gift, please confirm the recipient will be home to receive!
Ready for the bad news? They want $49 for this four-pack, and that is without shipping!
Recommended Reading: Is Jim Beam Good Whiskey
Who Manufactures Skrewball Whiskey
Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey is owned by Steve Yeng and Brittany Yeng. Over 200 active leaders in the alcoholic beverage industry named the brand the Best New Product at 2020s Market Watch Leaders Awards this past January, an award bestowed by industry insiders. Since its launch in 2019, the brand has grown by 500% and by 1,976%.
Also Check: What Juice Goes With Malibu Rum
Peanut Butter Irish Whiskey
What to mix with Skrewball? Coffee is a natural pairing with peanut butter whiskey! Make it into an Irish coffee by skipping the sugar and using Skrewball instead. Theres nothing more soul warming than that classic combination of bitter coffee, nutty whisky and frothy whipped cream.
Ingredients: Skrewball peanut butter whiskey, coffee, whipped cream
Heres a refreshing way to drink peanut butter whiskey: the classic Whiskey Highball! This two-ingredient cocktail originated around the turn of the 20th century and its still popular to this day. Pairing Skrewball with bubbles is delightfully refreshing.
Ingredients: Skrewball peanut butter whiskey, club soda
Also Check: Where To Order Whiskey Online
Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey 6 / Case
Prices shown are for Smith Street store only.Please call your local store for their pricing and availability.
Valentines Day Gift Guide | Specs Wines, Spirits & Finer Foods February 8, 2021
Peanut Butter Nut Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey
You must be logged in to post a review.
Receive an additional 5% discount in-store for cash payment. Prices and vintages subject to change.
Prices shown are for the Smith Street store only. Please call your local store for their pricing and availability.
Prices shown are for this location only and can vary by location. Please call your local store for their pricing and availability.
Also Check: Can You Drink Vodka On The Keto Diet
Also Check: What Are The Different Types Of Tequila
Where Can I Buy It
Because of everything going on with COVID-19, you really shouldnt be making an extra trip to the store right now. But that doesnt mean you cant get your hands on this whiskey. We recommend trying Drizly, an alcohol delivery service thatll bring booze right to your doorstep. Skrewballs peanut butter whiskey is offered there, as long as local stores have it for the carrier to deliver.
If Drizly isnt yet available in your area, theres always good ol fashioned online grocersincluding lesser-known ones that still have stuff you need in stock.
Chocolate Covered Pretzel Peanut Butter Cup & Banana Whiskey Sour
This recipe is quite simple and can be great for those who like a little sweet with their whiskey.
It starts by cutting up the bananas into slices, then freezing them so theyâll become nice and cold after this has been done youâll need to drizzle chocolate syrup in before stirring together until itâs fully mixed inâyou may want to use more or less depending on how strong you would like your drink! After that, stir in about one cup of sugar-free vanilla yogurt as well as some ice cubes if desired before enjoying this rich mixture! You can also garnish this drink by adding whipped cream on top if desired but try not to add too much since there are already plenty natural sugars included.
Read Also: Owner Of Don Julio Tequila
Recommended Reading: Is Bacardi Gold Rum Gluten Free
Is There A Peanut Butter Whiskey
Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey is as crazy as it sounds, and its made from real peanuts. Answer: Why not in response to a question like, why?. This American whiskey has a surprising sweetness, a smooth finish, and an unmistakable peanut butter flavour that pushes the boundaries of conventional wisdom.
Sheep Dog Peanut Butter Whiskey
Sheep Dog Peanut Butter whiskey is Sazeracs offering to the growing market of flavored drinks, released in 2020. This one does not have any actual peanuts or peanut butter components. Among the flavored whiskeys in the market, Sheep Dog stands different from the rest that uses natural peanut extract.
The palate is greeted with caramel, butterscotch, vanilla flavors, then the peanut butter kick. There is a lot of room for improvement in this bottle. Each 750 ml bottle is around $20.
Recommended Reading: How Many Calories Does Malibu Rum Have
Peanut Butter And Chile Vodka Cocktail
This drink recipe is perfect for those who enjoy spicy food or want to add a little complexity into their lives. It starts by combining vodka , frozen banana slices, and peanut butter in a blender after this has been blended together then youâll need one teaspoon of chile powder as well as some ice cubes for it to go down smoothly.
Peanut Butter And Bourbon Cocktail
Another flavor combination thatâs perfect for those who enjoy a little bit of sweet with their drink is peanut butter and bourbon. This recipe starts by combining ice cubes, ground cinnamon , honey , bourbon whiskey in a blender after this mixture has been blended together then youâll want to add some vanilla extract as well as chilled milk or creamâthese two ingredients should make up about one third of the total amount once blended.
You can also use other types of liquor if desired but it wonât be quite the same since theyâre not sweeter like bourbon which contains both sugar and caramelized corn syrup mixed into its grains during production which makes them taste more sugary than regular alcohol.
Also Check: What To Mix With Malibu Strawberry
Recommended Reading: Where To Buy Huckleberry Vodka