How To Make Whiskey Old Fashioned Sweet

Sugar Cube Or Simple Syrup

Fireball Whiskey Old Fashioned | Swamp Water or Sweet Elixir #1

Old Fashioned purists say the proper thing to do is to muddle a sugar cube with the bitters in the bottom of the rocks glass. Non-purists, like myself, think thats nice but the sugar never seems to fully dissolve this way. Either my muddling skills are weak , or there might be another way.

Im in favor of using simple syrup for an Old Fashioned because its easy and convenient. Heres how to make it.

What Is An Old Fashioned Drink

Before we move forward to sharing the old fashioned drink recipe, lets first unearth the delicious chronological study of the drink itself. For those who have never tried it once, the old fashioned drink is a form of cocktail. It contains muddling sugar with bitter and water. Moreover, it contains whiskey or brandy as its base. Although brandy is used in the drink less commonly. The drink is then garnished with an orange slice or lemon zest along with a cocktail cherry. Furthermore, the drink is served in an old-fashioned glass to elicit a sense of traditionalism.

The Balance and Columbian Repository in Hudson said of cocktails in 1806. They claimed that it is a mix of spirits, bitter, sugar, and water. It is the essential base of the old-fashioned drink. However, as time went by, the recipe became complex. Moreover, many new variations of cocktails also appeared throughout the era.

While most of the mixture of the drink used rum, gin, or brandy as the base, the inclusion of sugar and nutmeg as a garnish remained the same. With increasing complexity, many wanted something akin to the 1850s drink. Hence, the original cocktail remained in fashion even after many adaptations. Thus, it came to know as old-fashioned.

Dont: Muddle Your Cherries

If you prefer your Old Fashioned with a cherry, just make sure not to muddle it in the glass. This is not a drink that needs a bold punch of cherry flavor or fruit floating around. Instead, add it later as a garnish, and make sure to opt for a brand such as Luxardo over the neon maraschino cherry, which is full of chemicals and dye.

You May Like: Can You Buy Beer On Sunday In Florida

How To Make A Brandy Old Fashioned:

Just like my basil cocktail, this is a muddled drink.

In a double old fashioned glass , muddle the cherries, cherry juice, orange slice, sugar and bitters until everything is crushed and somewhat blended together.

Add the brandy and stir until everything is well combined and the sugar completely dissolves into the brandy.

Fill your glass with ice, and then top everything off with lemon-lime soda .

Manhattan Vs Old Fashioned

Manhattans and old fashioneds are popular whiskey-based cocktails. They have a lot in common, but there are a few key differences.

· An old fashioned is sweetened with sugar or simple syrup. The Manhattan’s sweetness comes from vermouth.· An old fashioned is garnished with an orange peel, while a Manhattan is garnished with a brandied cherry.· An old fashioned is served in a lowball glass, but a Manhattan is served in a stemmed martini glass.

You May Like: Kentucky Bourbon Trail In 2 Days

Whats The Difference Between Scotch And Bourbon

Bourbon whiskey is manufactured from a grain mash that comprises at least 51 percent corn, whereas Scotch whiskey is often prepared from malted grains, such as barley . Bourbon is often sweeter in flavor, but Scotch is typically smokier and more powerful in flavor. Summary. In terms of nutrients, bourbon and Scotch are equivalent.

Pro Tips For Making This Recipe

While some recipes may call for soda water or water added to the sugar cubes, I skip it so as not to dilute the cocktail.
Avoid adding too many dashes of bitters to the glass as itll overpower the bourbon flavors.
Dont skip the sugar as the sweetness opens the bourbons aroma.
When cutting the orange peel, make sure there is as little pith as possible as itll taste bitter.
To help your drink stay cold longer, you can place your glasses in the freezer beforehand. If you didnt put the glasses in the freezer early enough, you can also fill the glasses with some water and place them in the freezer while preparing to make the drink for a quick chill.
Feel free to double or triple the recipe, just be sure to use a larger glass to mix your ingredients together.
Using a large ice cube is ideal as it melts slower and slows the dilution of the drink.
A Luxardo cherry makes a great garnish for an Old Fashioned. Place it on a toothpick on the glass, or add it to the drink and stir.

Don’t Miss: Does Sam’s Club Sell Whiskey

Bourbon Old Fashioned Recipe

The classic recipe can easily be made using bourbon however the below recipe is a slight mix on it and makes for an equally lovely cocktail to drink. This recipe was made popular by Don Draper on the TV show Mad Men, so we sometimes refer to it as the Don Draper Old Fashioned or the American-style Old Fashioned instead.

Awesome photo from Gimmesomeoven

1 cube or teaspoon of sugar
3-4 dashes of angostura bitters
1 wheel of Orange & 1 Maraschino cherry
1 dash of club soda

Method

1. In a chilled glass, muddle together the sugar, bitters, wheel of orange, cherry and a dash of soda for 20-30 seconds

2. Take out the orange wheel and fill the glass with large ice cubes and your favourite bourbon

3. Garnish with a new orange wheel or peel and a Maraschino cherry. Optionally add a spritz of soda water if you want more dilution.

4. Enjoy your old fashioned cocktail!

How To Make A Perfect Old Fashioned

How to make an Old Fashion Sweet – The Wisconsin Way

Want to get a group of whiskey cocktail enthusiasts in a fun brawl? Claim to have the perfect old fashioned recipe. Youll never see a more lively discussion than a debate about muddling, base spirits and proper use of bitters.

There might be punches thrown, but there will definitely be insults traded.

Let me give you some background, then share what I believe is the perfect old fashioned recipe. If youre in a hurry, you can slip down to the recipe here.

Post may contain affiliate links.

Recommended Reading: The Story By Brandi Carlile

Learn How To Make A Classic Old Fashioned Cocktail Properly Its A Blend Of Bourbon Bitters Simple Syrup And The Best Cherries For A Well

post contains affiliate links.

Welp, weve finally done it. After about a year, J and I finally managed to carve out some time to make his favorite cocktail, an Old Fashioned, for all of you. If theres anything you should know about my hubby is that the man isprecise, particular and wellwere both a bit snobbish when it comes to cocktails.

In order to make a classic old fashioned cocktail, you need the right tools and the right ingredients to make the flavors of really great bourbon shine. I find the same to be true for Mint Juleps, too! You have to check out my recipe.

Jareds like me in that hell spend time crafting the perfect cocktail. After ordering so many too sweet or watered down Old Fashioned cocktails, he took the time to create his own recipe. Its stout, its unapologetic, bourbon forward and its delicious.

Where Did This Delectable Drink Come From

Wisconsin drinks more brandy than any other state Korbel has even reported that more than half of its world-wide sales go straight to Wisconsin. The popular myth explaining this phenomenon goes something like this: In 1893, the Worlds Columbian Exposition was in Chicago. Since it was just a train ride away, a lot of Wisconsinites were in attendance. German immigrants in this area already had a taste for brandy, and they latched onto Korbels product.

Jeanette Hurt, author of Wisconsin Cocktails, found another answer in her research. The story distills down to brandy being in the right place at the right time: Whisky was hard to get due to Prohibition and WWII, but the Christian Brothers had a stash of brandy on hand. Well-made brandy was favored over sub-par liquors, so more and more was distributed to Wisconsin until finally September was declared Wisconsin Brandy Old Fashioned Month last year.

Recommended Reading: Which Whiskey Stones Are Best

Don’t Miss: What Drinks Can I Mix With Vodka

How To Make An Old Fashioned With Whiskey

One of the most popular cocktails is the Old Fashioned which is made with whiskey . This cocktail is usually made with bourbon, but you can also use rye whiskey for a spicy touch. Make sure that you consider the bourbon you select when preparing an Old Fashioned as it can change its flavor profile significantly.

Variations On An Old Fashioned

In the early cocktail culture, old fashioneds were strictly designated for just whiskey, says Baker. Now, is used to describe a style of a cocktail, so you could technically use any spirit and turn it into an old fashioned.

Some popular variations include:

Quick tip: There are a few ways to balance your cocktail if it isnt quite right, according to Baker.

If it is too sweet, add a couple more dashes of bitters
If it is too strong, put it back into the mixing glass over ice and stir it for another 5 seconds.
If it is too bitter, add another 0.25 ounces more of sweetener.

Also Check: What To Mix Pinnacle Whipped Vodka With

How To Screw Up An Old Fashioned

In a cocktail with very few elements, one piece out of place can throw off the balance and whole flavor of the cocktail. Much depends on the choice of whiskey. Whatever whiskey you choose, make sure both the bitters, the simple syrup and garnish all work well together.

The easiest and most enjoyable way to figure this out would be experimentation where you change just one element in a series of cocktails and see which one suits you and your guests palates the best.

Im a purist at heart, so here are my 3 no-nos for an old fashioned:

#1: Adding Soda

Put down the soda, the seltzer, the lemon-lime soda. Just set it down and back away.

The beauty of well-crafted old fashioned is not only the way that it tastes on the first sip, but the way it mellows as the large chunk of ice dilutes in it. Adding soda to the cocktail might make the first sips very palatable for some, but the cocktail quickly becomes watered down and muted in flavor.We want to taste the whiskey in the old fashioned. Its why were here, after all.

#2: Using the Wrong Ice

In the original descriptions of the whiskey cocktail, it often mentioned that it required one large lump of ice. Today youre as likely to get one large cube as you are a glass full of smaller ice cubes. Even at home, making the cocktail for an evening cocktail, its easy to reach for refrigerator ice.But, using large cubes in your old fashioned does a few things.

#3: Muddling

The Best Bitters For An Old Fashioned

Angostura bitters is traditionally used in an Old Fashioned. Fun fact: Apparently Angostura bitters is kind of like Coca Cola, in that only five people on earth know the recipe, which reportedly consists of over 40 different herbs and spices!

You can’t go wrong with Angostura bitters, but if you’re making an Old Fashioned in the winter or around the holidays, I recommend using a few dashes of Fee Brothers Old Fashioned Bitters instead. You get way more cinnamon and clove on the nose, like a winter holiday in a bottle.

Don’t Miss: Where To Buy Whiskey Decanter

A Brandy Old Fashioned

Why brandy?

Apparently at the Chicago Worlds Fair in 1893, a new brandy distiller from California called Korbel was sampling their spirits.

Korbel began pouring the classic Old Fashioned whiskey cocktail using brandy, and the German crowd from Milwaukee took to the brandy and the cocktail in a big way.

The Dos And Donts Of The Brandy Old Fashioned

Whiskey Snobs and How to Make an Old Fashioned

Dont overthink your choice of brandyKorbel isnt highbrow, but more than a century of drinkers cant be wrong. If it aint broke

Do muddleIf you want more fruit flavor and a slightly smoother Old Fashioned.

Dont muddleIf you like to taste your booze and prefer a drink with a little more bite. Do know your optionsYou can customize your Old Fashioned. Sweet comes with a splash of Sprite/7UP, sour with Squirt/sour, and press is topped with a splash of both Sprite/7UP and club soda.

Don’t Miss: How Much Alcohol In Gin And Tonic

Best Rye Old Fashioned Recipes

This is for the whiskey lover who wants a cocktail but expects to taste the whiskey. Theres no better choice than a rye Old-Fashioned. An Old-Fashioned is the godfather of whiskey cocktails. It is whiskey forward, potent, yet uncomplicated:

2 ounces rye whiskey
Orange and/or lemon peel garnish
One very large ice cube

This simple recipe has stood the test of time. Truly. Rye was the traditional type of whiskey around the 19th century when the Old-Fashioned made its debut. While the recipe has seen numerous variations , the staples remain consistent keeping this particular cocktail at the head of the pack.

Garnish Your Old Fashioned Like A Wisconsinite

Cherries are an obvious choice , but lots of people choose olives or pickled mushrooms. Good bars will even stock pickled Brussels sprouts, so you could choose that as well.

If youre making these drinks at home, cherries and olives are a great start. If you like and will use the pickled mushrooms, get those, too.

You May Like: Mojito With Simple Syrup Recipe

Garnish Your Brandy Old Fashioned Like A Wisconsinite

Regardless of how you like your old fashioned, theres one thing you dont want to skip, and thats the garnish. If you order an old fashioned at a bar in Wisconsin, youll be asked what kind of garnish you want. Cherries are an obvious choice , but lots of people choose olives or pickled mushrooms. Good bars will even stock pickled Brussels sprouts, so you could choose that as well.

If youre making these drinks at home, cherries and olives are a great start. If you like and will use the pickled mushrooms, get those, too.

Check Out The Conversation Here

Tim McKirdy: Hey, this is Tim McKirdy, and welcome to VinePairs Cocktail College, a weekly deep dive into classic cocktails that goes beyond the recipe with Americas best bartenders. The Old Fashioned might not lay claim to the title of worlds oldest cocktail, but its influence on modern mixology, and its place in popular culture is unquestionable. Put simply, in todays world, any bartender worth their salt has to have perfected the Old Fashioned. Today, were going to learn how to do that with Eric Alperin, best known as the co-owner of The Varnish in L.A., a bar he opened in 2009 with his mentor, the late Sasha Petraske. Beyond ingredients, ratios, and building techniques, were going to explore things like the importance of ice, the overlap of theater and mixology, and why this drink, more than any other, is so closely tied to the revival of cocktail culture. Well also hear from Eric about how he schooled one of Hollywoods biggest names on how to make the Old Fashioned, which culminated in what is, perhaps, the best cocktail creation scene in cinematic history. Do you know which one were talking about? Buckle up, listener. Were about to find out. Eric Alperin, welcome to the show. Thank you so much for joining us.

Eric Alperin: Absolutely, Tim. Thanks for having me on this inaugural journey. I think this is No. 1, right?

T: This is No. 1. Im looking forward to taking these first steps with you in the audio land.

E: We will bravely go together.

Blackberry Brandyeasier Than Pie

Like many fruits and berries, blackberries have a pretty short season. If youre lucky enough to live in a place where you can pick your own fresh berries in fields or hedgerows, you can preserve the flavor of those luscious berries by making jams and preserves. For an extra special treat, how about some Blackberry Brandy?

Making your own blackberry brandy is easier than making a blackberry pie!

Warning: When picking wild berries, make sure you get them from a place that has not been sprayed with weed killers or pesticides!

What Kind Of Whiskey To Use In An Old

The old-fashioned is one of the best ways to dress up your favorite whiskey without significantly altering the taste. If you’re a traditionalist, you might prefer rye whiskey. The bourbon old-fashioned is a popular choice as well it was the go-to style of whiskey for this iconic drink for years. Whichever whiskey you pour, the sweet, bitter, and fruit flavors added to the glass will enhance it nicely.

Also Check: What Is The Best Rum

What Is Angostura Bitters & Why Do I Need It In My Old Fashioned

The use of angostura bitters was originally medicinal, to treat digestive problems. This carried over to being used with soda water, to treat sailors with upset stomachs. Later gin was added, which is of course, where Angostura in what would later become known as cocktails. First got its usage. Of course it is more famed for its use in Old Fashioned, but it has other purpose.

It is created through repeated cooking, straining & infusing processes over a period of 20+ days, the ingredients for different bitters varies on which bitters you buy, or even make, as many Mixologists now are creating their own infusions for this product.

Old fashioned cocktail at home

Recommended Reading: Pinnacle Root Beer Vodka Recipes